PhD Students - Jörg Wiegratz
Details
email : J.Wiegratz@sheffield.ac.uk
Thesis Title: The cultural political economy of
embedding neoliberalism in Uganda: an analysis of changes in moral norms and trade practices in the rural economy since 1986 (provisional)
Start Year: 2007
Supervisors
Research Topic
Uganda is regarded as the African country that has adopted the neoliberal reform package most extensively. Notably, neoliberal reforms have targeted the reshaping not only of the economy but also of the society and culture. The reforms aim at the emergence and consolidation of `market society´
(free-market, capitalist social relations), which includes a corresponding set of moral norms of behaving and relating to each other (homo economicus,
self-interest, individualism, utility maximizing behaviour, transaction-based relations, money).
Reforms,therefore, have to undermine, overwrite and displace pre-existing norms,values, orientations, valuations and practices among the population. Particularly noteworthy is the attempt to change, directly or indirectly, moral norms. That means changing what is regarded acceptable and unacceptable, proper and improper, legitimate and illegitimate behaviour in the light of the moral
principles in the country. Reengineering morals therefore also entails changing the criteria by which people evaluate each other´s (and their own) actions.
My research is on moral restructuring in Uganda since 1986, when the 1981-86 guerrilla war ended and the current ruling party, the National Resistance Movement, (NRM) rose to power. That research reveals that this cultural dimension of rapid neoliberal reform has negatively affected the relationships
and trade practices between smallholder farmer(peasants) and traders in rural markets. Extensive interviews in Kampala and eastern Uganda suggest that since the onset of liberal economic reforms (liberalisation, deregulation, privatisation), face-to-face rural trade practices have been characterised by higher levels of `malpractice´ and a change in their form. These malpractices include deception, intimidation, theft, collusion, corruption, and various manipulations regarding price, quality and quantity.
In general, the changing moral and political economy in the country since 1986 has led to increasingly unconstrained moneymaking, in which those with social,
economic and political power pursue their self interest almost without regard for the costs to others. Related to this is a focus on quick profits with little regard for quality or for longer-term considerations. This self-interest is being rationalised, supported and justified by a new set of neoliberal orientations, norms and discourses that increasingly govern Ugandan economy and society, as they increasingly govern life in other countries undergoing neoliberal reform, and they bring with them undesirable consequences (which, in turn, further affect the moral restructuring process and the malpractice trend).
The research tries to track and explain these changes, especially the change in business practices and underlying moral norms, by exploring people´s
experiences, views and interpretations, and by tracing the history of rural trade relationships and practices in the country. The research also considers
the part played in the shifting moral economy by a variety of institutions that affect people´s daily lives, including councils, the police and judiciary,
churches, financial institutions, advertising firms, NGOs and donors/aid agencies (which were particularly adamant in pushing for the neoliberal reforms). More generally, the analysis captures the ways that embedding a neoliberal business culture changes not only the political economy but also the moral order of local markets, communities and the country at large. For a more detailed overview of the preliminary findings see the summary document on this
website. The thesis should be submitted in August, 2010. Any comments or further information will be appreciated.
Research Interests
Political economy and related aspects of sociology & anthropology, Sub-Saharan Africa/Uganda, neoliberalism, moral economy, development, global economy (production, value chain governance, business culture, economic malpractice, deception), capitalist society, aspects of socialization & learning(education, training)
Academic Degrees
- 2003 - MA in International Political Economy, University of Warwick (UK)
- 2002 - MA in Economics (Diplom-Volkswirt), University of Cologne (Germany), courses taken in: economics, business administration, political science, sociology and communication science/journalism
Authored Publications
- ‘Fake capitalism? The dynamics of neoliberal moral restructuring and pseudo-development: the case of Uganda’, Review of African Political Economy (ROAPE), Issue 124, June, 2010
- Uganda’s Human Resource Challenge: Training, Business Culture and Economic Development,
Fountain Publishers, Kampala, ISBN: 978-9970-02-968-6, 434pp., 2009 - ‘Beyond harsh trade!? The relevance of 'soft' competitiveness factors for Ugandan enterprises to endure in Global Value Chains’, African Journal of Business and Law (AJOBAL), 2 (1), pp. 2-22, 2008
- Capabilities for catching-up: Economic development and competitiveness in Uganda: Implications for Human Resource Development with particular focus on Technical and Vocational Education and Training in Uganda, summary of a background report for the German Technical Cooperation (GTZ), Kampala: GTZ, 2006.
- Human resource development for accelerated economic development in Uganda, background study for GTZ, accepted by book publisher, 420pp.
Co-authored Publications
- Case studies of lead firm governance systems in the context of commercialization of smallholder agriculture in Uganda, with P. Nyabuntu,and C. Omagor, Research study for the Uganda Programme for Trade Opportunities and Policy (UPTOP), 416pp., Kampala: UPTOP, 2007.
- Competing and Learning in Global Value Chains - Firms’ experiences in the case of Uganda, A study of five export sub-sectors with reference to trade between Uganda and Europe, with P. Nyabuntu and C. Omagor, UPTOP Research study, 471pp., Kampala: UPTOP, 2007, accepted by book publisher.
Contributed Publications
- Industrial Competitiveness Report Uganda and Industrial Policy Uganda, UN Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO), Vienna: UNIDO, 2007.
- Inserting Local Industries into Global Value Chains and Production Networks: What Opportunities and Challenges for Upgrading?, Vienna: UNIDO, 2005.
Publications in newspapers/periodicals
- ‘The neglected side of Uganda’s liberal
economic reforms’, The Independent, Issue 107, 16.-23.04.2010, http://www.independent.co.ug/index.php/column/opinion/86-opinion/2808-the-neglected-side-of-ugandas-liberal-economic-reforms- - The effects of economic liberalization on
Uganda’, The Uganda Record, Vol. 1, No 65, 09.04.2010, http://ugandarecord.co.ug/index.php?issue=65&article=810&seo=The%20effects%20of%20economic%20liberalization%20on%20Uganda
Conference Papers
- ‘Cultural occupation and cultural restructuring: again? The foreign powers' neoliberal project in Uganda’, Sheffield International Development Network, Postgraduate Conference, Sheffield, 07.03.2011
- ‘The neoliberal harvest: the proliferation and normalisation of economic deceit in a market society’, Deviancy Conference: Critical perspectives on crime, deviance, disorder and social harm, University of York, 29.06.-01.07.2011
- ‘The morality of economic malpractice and crime in
neoliberal capitalism’, BISA Annual Conference 2011, Manchester, 27.-29.04.2011 - ‘Forcing a market society into being: The destructive dynamics of moral restructuring in neoliberal Uganda’, Re-thinking Global Society, University of Leeds, in recognition of the launch
the Bauman Institute, 06.07.09.2010. - ‘Cultural occupation? Analysing the foreign forces of neoliberal moral restructuring in Uganda’, ‘The Commonwealth at 60: Transitions, Belonging and Identities’, University of Sheffield, Department of History, 04.06.2010
- ‘The cultural political economy of moral restructuring in Uganda’, Biennial conference of the German Association for African Studies (VAD), ‘Continuities, dislocations and Transformations: Reflections on 50 Years of African Independence’, Panel 24: Privately regulated spaces: Articulations and disarticulations of neoliberalism in Africa, Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz, 07.-11.4.2010
- ‘The cultural political economy of embedding neoliberalism in Uganda: Moral restructuring, rural trade and the rise in malpractice since 1986’, Democratization in Africa: Retrospective and Future Prospects, Panel: ‘Democracy and Local Power III’, University of Leeds, 04.-05.12.2009.
- ‘The cultural political economy of embedding neoliberalism in Uganda - analysing moral economy
dynamics of trade practices between farmers and traders since 1986’, Millennium Annual Conference,‘After Liberalism?’, Panel: 'Liberalism in Africa: putting theory into practice', London School ofEconomics and Political Science, 17-18.10.2009 - Integrating, Competing and Learning in GVCs: The relevance of soft competitiveness factors for Ugandan enterprises to succeed, Pre-CHOGM (Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting) conference on ‘Transforming society: Commonwealth Perspectives on the nexus between civil society and business’, Kampala, 03-05.10.2007.
- Is export-led growth a possibility? A qualitative assessment of Uganda’s export policies over the last 15 years 1990/91-2005/06, with G. Ssemogerere (Makerere University) presented at the ‘National Policy Conference on Sustaining Growth in Uganda’, Kampala, 30-31.10.2006
Presentations
- ‘The cultural political economy of neoliberal moral Restructuring: insights from Uganda’, University of York, Department of Politics, Politics Research Seminar Series, 09.06.2010
- ‘Marching towards market societies in Africa? The case of Uganda’, University of Leeds, Centre for African Studies (LUCAS), 03.03.2010.
- ‘The business culture dimension of trade between Africa and the European Union: The case of Uganda (and beyond)’, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, Centre of African Studies, Africa Business Group Series, 03.02.2010.
- ‘The cultural political economy of neoliberal moral restructuring: The case of Uganda’, Annual Meeting of the Working Group on Morality and Profession (‘Moral und Beruf’), University of Basel, 15.16.1.2010.
- ‘The cultural political economy of embedding neoliberalism in Uganda - An analysis of changes in relationships and trade practices between farmers and traders in the context of post-1986 economic liberalisation reforms’, held at the following Workshops in Kampala: NGO Forum, 09.04.2009, EPRC, 08.04.2009, Centre for Basic Research (CBR), 08.04.2009, Organization for Social Science Research in Eastern and Southern Africa (OSSREA), 13.3.2009
- ‘Issues in trade relationships and practices between farmers and traders in neoliberal Uganda’, Agrarian Change Seminars, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, 22.10.2009
- ‘Are we really studying 'the economy' yet? Reflections about research on 'markets' and 'actors' in Uganda’, MUBS, Faculty of Commerce, Research Day, 13.3.2009
- ‘The political economy of neoliberal business culture in Uganda - Conceptual and empirical reflections’, Uganda Christian University (UCU), Mbale Campus Study Centre, 07.03.2009
- ‘Studying real markets - understanding the embeddedness of economic action’, Islamic University in Uganda (IUIU), Mbale, 03.03.2009
- ‘Doing chain analysis in the field’, Workshop of the Commodity Studies Working Group of the International Initiative for Promoting Political Economy (IIPPE),London (SOAS), 08.03.2008
- 'Case studies of lead firm governance systems in the context of commercialization of smallholder agriculture in Uganda', Dissemination Workshops for the research project, Kampala, 05.09./14.09.2007.
- 'Integrating, Competing and Learning in GVCs: The relevance of soft competitiveness factors for Ugandan enterprises to succeed', Economic Policy Research Centre, Research seminar, Kampala, 29.08.2007.
- 'Competing and Learning in GVCs: Firms’ experiences in the case of Uganda’, Makerere University Business School (MUBS), Research Seminar, Kampala, 10.05.2007 as well as Dissemination Workshop: UPTOP Research Projects, Kampala, 16.03.2007.
- 'A critical assessment of trade and trade policy in Africa', Centre of Basic Research, Kampala, 11.11.2004.
- Uganda: Towards an Industrial Policy Framework for industrial competitiveness and sustainability, National Consultative Meeting on Industrial Development, Team presentation, Kampala, 21.09.2004.
Other Presentations
- ‘People, power, practice: a moral economy approach to rural poverty in neoliberal Africa, insights from Uganda’, Workshop on ‘Rural Eonomies in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Global Politics of Local Change’, Institute of Advanced Studies, University of Warwick, 14.09.2010
Teaching
- POL226 Comparative Politics: Citizens, States, Power, and Protest (University of Sheffield)
- POL 111 The Politics of Globalisation (University of Sheffield)
- POL 109 Comparing Modern Polities (University of Sheffield)
- POL 107 The Globalization of World Politics (University of Sheffield)
- ACE2107 History of Political Ideas (University of Sheffield)
- Aspects of International Economics (Makerere University)
Professional Affiliations
- British International Studies Association (BISA), BISA International Political Economy Group (IPEG) and BISA Africa and International Relations working group
- African Studies Association UK (ASA UK)
- Global Value Chain Initiative (www.globalvaluechains.org)
- Research Associate, Economic Policy Research Centre, Kampala (www.eprc.or.ug)
- Associate tutor: University of Sheffield; Part-time lecturer: Makerere University (Faculty of Economic and Management) and Makerere University Business School (appointed).
- Organisation for Social Science Research in Eastern and Southern Africa (OSSREA), Network of German speaking Morality researchers, African
Studies Association in Germany (VAD)
Other Work
2007: Resource Person: Makerere University.
2006-07: Researcher and Consultant: UPTOP and GTZ.
2004-05: Junior Consultant: for UNIDO, attached to the Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Industry of the Republic of Uganda (Department of Industry and Technology).
2003-04: Intern: UNIDO, Strategic Research and Economics Branch.
